We are full-fledged, contributing members of Quebec society

Dear Premier Legault,

As proud Quebecers, we reject your government’s impractical and ill-advised decision to label our community as “historic Anglophones” and your plan to limit government services to citizens who are eligible to attend English schools.

Our community is an integral part of Quebec with full rights to participate in Quebec society and to receive government services. We are not some folkloric ‘historic’ group. We are full-fledged Quebecers, who are committed to building an inclusive Quebec where French is the common language. Our institutions serve all Quebecers and are among the fleurons du Québec – world-class educational, research, and health care establishments that attract top notch scientists and researchers working on leading edge technology that benefits all Quebecers as well as our economy.

We remind you that eligibility to attend school in English in Quebec is not in any way linked to the language of the student or the parent. Rather, it is linked to the language of instruction received by the parent or the previous educational pathway of the student. Thus, the English-speaking minority does not coincide with the ‘English-school-eligible’ category. Many members of the English-speaking community attended French schools in order to perfect their knowledge of Quebec’s common language; under your proposal, they would not qualify to receive written services in English. Meanwhile, ironically, Francophones who attended English schools in their youth would have the right to receive the services in English.

Most importantly, the use of the ‘English-school-eligible’ category is grossly under-inclusive. It removes the right to receive services including health care in English from between 300,000 and 500,000 English-speaking Quebecers.  It is utterly divorced from our community’s self-identification.

More broadly, the attempt to create categories of citizens who are eligible for certain services is deeply troublesome from a public governance perspective. Minorities define themselves; they are not defined by the state. The English-speaking minority of Quebec does not define itself based on the ‘English-school-eligible’ category, and the expanded use of this category is offensive.

Premier Legault, your government should not be attempting to define our community or limiting our access to government services, whether for critical health and social services or the right to pay our taxes in English. As Premier Lucien Bouchard famously stated in 1996 at the Centaur theatre: “When you go to the hospital and you are in pain, you may need a blood test, but you certainly don’t need a language test.”

We believe that the right to communication and services in English should never be based on eligibility for English instruction. We are confident that the status quo reflects the values and generosity of spirit of all Quebecers.

Email us your full name at to join the list of full-fledged Quebecers who have signed this letter.

Clifford Lincoln

Frank Baylis

Eleni Bakopanos

David Berger

Joan Fraser

David Angus

Dan Lamoureux

Marcus Tabachnick

Michael Murray

Judy Kelley

Stephen Burke

John Ryan

Joe Ortona

Dr. Bernard Shapiro

Ram Panda

Christopher Shannon

Julius Grey

Michael Bergman

Frank Schlesinger

Pearl Eliadis

Casper Bloom

Bruce McNiven

Theodore Goloff

Brent Tyler

Jack Jedwab

Campbell Stuart

Russell Copeman

Lawrence Bergman

Robert Libman

Bob Benedetti

Victor Drury

Norman Steinberg

Jonathan Wener

Abraham Fuks

Dr. Nicolas Steinmetz

Dr Richard Creuss

Dr. Sylvia Creuss

Judy Martin

Sheilagh Murphy

Dr. Mark Roper

Robert Kleinman

Shaheen Ashraf

Al Abdon

Rabbi Lisa Grushcow

Dr. Clarence Bayne

Rev. Diane Rollert

Stanley Plotnick

Sharon Nelson

Mark Henry

Anna Gainey

Royal Orr

Martin Murphy

Geoffrey Chambers

Joan F. Ivory

Fergus Keyes

Peter G. White

Thomas Ledwell

Richard Smith

Stuart H. (Kip) Cobbett

Julia Gersovitz

Harrold Simpkins

Christopher Neal

Diana Nicholson

Gemma Raeburn-Baynes

Murielle Parkes

Cynthia Price Verreault

Ruth Pelletier

Marina Boulos-Winton

Nick Maturo

Elsa Bolam

Terry Mosher

Barry Lazar


Marlene Jennings

Eva Ludvig

Matt Aronson

Kevin Shaar

Eric Maldoff

Alix Adrien

Maureen Kiely

Sandra K. de la Ronde

Anna Farrow

Katherine Korakakis

Matt Harrington

Kent Hovey-Smith

Gerald Cutting

Walter Duszara

Linda Leith

John S. Bailey

Chad Bean

Deirdre McIlwraith

Andrew de Courcy-Ireland

Désirée McGraw

Kenneth Matziorinis

Margot McFarlane-Hall

Catherine Gilbert

Click here to view the names of more individuals who have signed this letter.


Resolution on the Definition of Quebec’s English-speaking Community

WHEREAS during his inaugural address to the National Assembly on October 19, 2021, Premier François Legault stated:

“I want to speak to the historic English-speaking community of Quebec. You are an integral part of Quebec. As a historic community, you have your own institutions: Schools, colleges, universities, hospitals, the media. Canada’s francophone minorities dream of mastering so many institutions. No minority in Canada is better served than English-speaking Quebecers and we are proud of that.”

WHEREAS the following day Premier Legault defined the historic English-speaking community as those individuals who are eligible for English schooling in Quebec;

WHEREAS eligibility to attend school in English in Quebec is not in any way linked to the language of the student or the parent. Rather, it is linked to the language of instruction received by the parent or the educational pathway of the student or his or her siblings. Meanwhile, ironically, Francophones who attended English schools and their children would be provided the right to receive government services in English;

WHEREAS the use of the ‘English-eligible’ category in Bill 96 is grossly under-inclusive – eliminating the right to access services in English for between 300,000 and 500,000 English-speaking Quebecers – and is entirely disconnected from the community’s self-identification;

WHEREAS under international norms minorities define themselves; they are not defined by the state;

WHEREAS any attempt to discriminate by creating categories of citizens then deemed eligible to receive certain government services is deeply troublesome from a public governance perspective;

WHEREAS English-speaking Quebecers are full and contributing members of Quebec society who are committed to building an inclusive Quebec where French is the common language.


Any attempt by the Government of Quebec to define the English-speaking Quebecers as an ‘historic’ community or limit their right to receive government communications and services in English is profoundly objectionable. Furthermore, rights and services should never be based on eligibility for English instruction.

Organizations endorsing Bill 96 Resolution

Almage Senior Community Centre

Atwater Library and Computer Centre

Avante Women’s Centre

Batshaw Youth and Family Centres Foundation

Black Community Resource Centre (BCRC)

Canadian Hellenic Congress

Catholic Action Montreal

Chez Doris

City of Westmount

Coasters Association

Community Economic Development and Employability Corporation – CEDEC

Contactivity Centre

Côte Saint-Luc Municipal Council

English Language Arts Network (ELAN)

English Montreal School Board 

English Parents’ Committee Association (EPCA)

English-Speaking Catholic Council (ESCC)

Eva Marsden Center for Social Justice and Aging

Filipino Heritage Society of Montreal (FHSM)

Gay and Grey Montreal

Greene Avenue Community Centre

Habilitas Foundation

Handicap Life Dignity

Heritage Lower Saint Lawrence

Jamaica Association of Montreal (JAM)

Lakeshore General Hospital Foundation

La Collective des femmes – Nicolet et région

Linda Leith Publishing

McGill University Health Centre Foundation

Mental Health Estrie  

Miriam Foundation

Montreal Council of Women

Native Women’s Shelter of Montreal

Phelps Helps

Provincial Council of Women of Quebec

Quebec Association of Independent Schools (QAIS)

Quebec English School Boards Association (QESBA)

Quebec Community Newspaper Association (QCNA)

Quebec Writers’ Federation

Quebec Counselling Association (QCA) 

RECAA Respecting Elders: Communities Against Abuse

Regional Association of West Quebecers (RAWQ)

Saint Columba House

Secretariat of the Black Community Forum (BCF)

Seniors Action Quebec

South Asian Women’s Community Centre Council (SAWCC)

Quebec Community Groups Network (QCGN)

Quebec 4-H Association (4-H Quebec)

The Townships Sun 

Townshippers’ Association

Tyndale St-Georges Community Centre

Union United Church

Uplands Cultural and Heritage Centre

UrbanNature Education

West Island Black Community Association (WIBCA)

Williams Recognition

YES Employment + Entrepreneurship